Frank Snepp, a former CIA operative who
published information about U.S. activities at the time of the fall of Saigon to the North Vietnamese, notably the agency's failure to try to protect its indigenous agents, says Edward Snowden should
accept punishment for his disclosures.
Government prosecutors never accused me of betraying classified
secrets. But in 1980, the Supreme Court decided that I had "irreparably
harmed" national security by publishing my book without official
approval, in violation of CIA nondisclosure agreements. This, the court
said, harmed the government's ability to prevent serious leaks.
The
ruling left me destitute, stigmatized and gagged for life, required to
clear with the CIA all my spy-related writings, including this one, with
the threat of jail time if I screw up. The 1st Amendment also took a
hit with the rulings in my case. Now, all intelligence alumni, Snowden
included, can be severely punished for merely speaking out about their
work, regardless of whether what they say contains any classified
information.
Yet, for all that I suffered
personally, I never ran or tried to hide. And when the time came to face
the music, I never bargained for mercy. I simply took my lumps,
accepting them as the price we pay in a democracy for the right to speak
out.
I agree. Snowden is no Ellsberg.
No comments:
Post a Comment